Collectibles Non-Sport Trading Cards Benchwarmer Trading Card Singles
2008 BENCHWARMER JESSICA ROCKWELL LINGERIE CARD - Gold Foil parallel
$3.99
Benchwarmer 2010 Signature Series JAIMARIE Autograph Card #37A AUTO
$3.50
2017 Benchwarmer America Super Flag Patch SF15 Hiromi Oshima Flag
$13.00
Benchwarmer 2010 Signature Series JESSICA HALL Autograph Card #20A AUTO
$4.00
KAREN McDOUGAL Playboy Collector Update #6PY Playmate of the Year HOT CARD !
$2.00
2018 18 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER 4 HFT ANDREA LOWELL CLASS CUTS HAIR CARD /5
$18.27
MARY RILEY 2016 BENCHWARMER DERRIERE CARD /4 BUTT CARD
$32.00
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER HEATHER RAE YOUNG SUPER FLAG PATCH CARD /1 1/1
$0.99
2017 DYLAN FITZPATRICK BENCHWARMER 2/3 WORLD MODELS INTERNATIONAL FLAG PATCH
$6.00
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER JAIME HAMMER AUTOGRAPH KISS CARD /5
$0.99
2017 NIKKI LEIGH BENCHWARMER 1/2 DREAMGIRLS PURPLE FOIL PREVIEW AUTOGRAPH CARD
$7.00
Melissa Riso Benchwarmer Gold Edition Autograph Card /5
$7.01
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER 4 HFT KATIE LOHMANN CLASS CUTS HAIR CARD 2/2 /2
$2.25
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER LORIN HARTWELL BLUE FOIL FLAG PATCH CARD /2
$4.25
Benchwarmer 2015 MASUIMI MAX Authentic Panty Swatch HOT !
$5.70
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER HIROMI OSHIMA NAUGHTY SCHOOL GIRL BUTT CARD /10
$0.99
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER 4 TIFFANY TAYLOR RED FOIL BASE CARD # 51 1/1 /1
$0.99
DANI MATHERS Playboy Collector Update #9PY Playmate of the Year 2015, HOT CARD !
$2.00
2018 18 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER 4 ANDREA LOWELL MILK MONEY COINS CARD 1/2 /2
$2.25
2018 BENCHWARMER CARD HOT FOR SCHOOL GIRL SWATCH ATHENA LUNDBERG 3/5 GOLD
$3.25
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER CAROLYN MARTIN NAUGHTY SCHOOL GIRL BUTT CD /10
$20.50
Kassie Lyn Logsdon Eclectic Swatch Card ~ 2014 Bench Warmer ~
$5.99
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER ASHLEY DORIS NAUGHTY SCHOOL GIRL BUTT CARD /10
$0.99
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER MARY RILEY LUNCH MONEY CURRENCY CARD /2
$1.30
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER 4 ANDREA LOWELL RED FOIL BASE CARD # 62 1/1 /1
$0.99
MARKETS JANSKA Playboy Centerfold Update #13 Playmate Base Card HOT !!
$2.00
ALYSSA ARCE Playboy Centerfold Update #37 Playmate Base Card HOT !!
$2.00
2018 BENCHWARMER CARD HOT FOR TEACHER MILK MONEY TABITHA TAYLOR 2/2 GREEN FOIL
$7.50
Michelle McLaughlin Eclectic Swatch Card ~ 2014 Bench Warmer ~
$5.99
Raquel Pomplun Benchwarmer DreamGirls Goodnight Kiss Autograph Card /5
$7.50
2018 BENCHWARMER CARD HOT 4 TEACHER NAUGHTY SCHOOL GIRL CASSIE CARDELLE 3/3 GREE
$16.50
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER MELISSA RISO NAUGHTY GIRL BUTT CARD SP 03/10
$25.00
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER TRA'SHELL THOMPSON SUPER FLAG PATCH CARD 1/1 /1
$0.99
2018 MEGAN HAUSERMAN BENCHWARMER 1/1 HOT4TEACHER NAUGHTY SCHOOL GIRL CARD
$60.00
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER TRASHELL THOMPSON NAUGHTY SCHOOL GIRL BUTT /10
$20.50
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER 4 SHELLY MARTINEZ FLAG PATCH CARD 1/1 ONE OF /1
$6.50
2018 BENCHWARMER CARD HOT FOR SCHOOL GIRL SWATCH RYAN SHAMROCK 5/5 GOLD
$2.80
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER 4 KENNEDY SUMMERS EXTRA CREDIT GEMS CARD 1/1 /1
$5.50
KARA MONACO Playboy Collector Update #2PY Playmate of the Year 2006 Card HOT !
$2.00
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER DYLAN FITZPATRICK MILK MONEY COINS CARD /3
$7.00
DALENE KURTIS (CURTIS) Playboy Centerfold Update #42 Playmate Base Card HOT !!
$2.00
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER TORRIE WILSON CLASS CUTS HAIR CUT CARD /5
$31.00
Carmen Electra Lady Luck Kiss Card ~ 2013 Bench Warmer ~ Signature 11 of 11
$9.99
Benchwarmer 2015 National Nikki Ziering 2/6 Autograph Black Ink Card
$1.00
2018 BENCHWARMER CARD HOT FOR TEACHER MILK MONEY PATRICE HOLLIS 1/2 GREEN FOIL
$6.00
2005 BENCHWARMER  SIGNED VERSION 6/10 KISS PRINT HOLLY MADISON NICE! "RARE" 
$8.55
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER 4 CASSIE CARDELLE MILK MONEY COINS CARD 1/2 /2
$2.25
2013 April Scott Signature Series Autograph Benchwarmer Card
$1.25
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER 4 TIFFANY SELBY PINK SCHOOLGIRL SWATCH CARD /4
$2.55
2016 Benchwarmer Dreamgirls Odds & Ends Green Foil Stephanie Branton 3/3
$18.50
HIROMI OSHIMA Playboy Centerfold Update #4EC Playmate Editors Choice RARE HOT !!
$2.00
CARMELLA DECESARE Playboy Collector Update #3PY Playmate of the Year HOT CARD !
$2.00
Benchwarmer 2011 Paige Peterson Limited Gold Auto Autograph
$0.99
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER GEMMA LEE FARRELL GOLD FOIL BASE CARD /25
$0.99
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER DANI MATHERS GOLD FOIL BASE CARD /25
$0.99
Raquel Pomplun Benchwarmer American Gems Card 1/2
$10.50
Benchwarmer 2010 Signature Series ALISON WAITE 49/50 Purple Autograph Card #79A
$4.99
Playboy Lingerie Seduction DITA VON TEESE Editors Choice Gold Foil Insert Card
$1.89
Holli Pockets 2018 Bench Warmer Hot For Teacher Class Cuts Hair Gold /5
$21.50
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER 4 HFT TIFFANY SELBY RING CARD 1/1 ONE OF ONE /1
$32.00
Benchwarmer 2011 Jennifer Korbin Holiday Gold Foil Auto Autograph
$0.99
Cassie Cardelle Valentine ~ 2014 Bench Warmer ~ Signature in Pink
$1.99
2005 Mary Riley Locker Room Insert Bench Warmer Card
$0.99
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER PEGGY TANOUS SCHOOL GIRLS ICE BLUE AUTO /1 1/1
$0.99
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER AMANDA PAIGE NAUGHTY SCHOOL GIRL BUTT CARD /10
$25.00
2018 Benchwarmer Extra Credit Gems Red Ciara Price Triple Patch 1/1
$5.50
2018 LINGERIE SEDUCTION Ditta Von Teese Editors Choice CARD #10EC
$5.00
Irina Voronina Playboy Centerfold Update Base Card #25HOT!
$2.00
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER CASSANDRA LYNN GOLD FOIL BASE CARD /25
$0.99
JAYDE NICOLE Playboy Collector Update #8PY Playmate of the Year Card HOT !
$2.00
2017 AUDREY ALEEN ALLEN BENCHWARMER 1/1 DREAMGIRLS UPDATE RED FOIL BASE CARD
$14.00
Benchwarmer 2016 Sandra Taylor Dreamdate Gold Foil Auto Autograph
$0.99
Kayla Collins Swatch Card ~ 2014 Bench Warmer ~
$5.99
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER 4 MICHELLE BAENA GREEN FOIL BASE CARD # 26 /3
$0.99
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER ANDREA LOWELL GOLD FOIL BASE CARD # 62 1/25 /25
$0.99
Victoria Fuller 2005 Bench Warmer Regular Authentic Bikini Swatch - Yellow
$14.50
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER 4 CASSIE CARDELLE GOLD FOIL BASE CARD # 67 /25
$0.99
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER PEGGY TANOUS INSCRIPTIONS AUTOGRAPH CARD /4
$1.25
2016 Benchwarmer Pink Archive AUBRIE LEMON Silver Foil Autograph
$1.00
****Stephani Costanza 2014 Benchwarmer Hot For Teacher Gold Foil Auto # 84
$3.99
Playboy Lingerie Seduction MORENA CORWIN Card
$1.89
2018 BENCHWARMER CARD HOT 4 TEACHER SERIES 4 YEARBOOK AUTOGRAPH SPENCER SCOTT
$0.99
Nikki Leigh 2017 Bench Warmer America Beautiful God Bless Flag Patch Blue 2/2
$19.50
BENCHWARMER LIMITED; 10 CARD HALLOWEEN SET
$0.99
JESSICA BURCIAGA 10/10 2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER NAUGHTY SCHOOL GIRL bj1
$21.00
Sara Underwood 2012 Bench Warmer Daizy Dukez Kara Monaco Jeans Swatch Pink /15
$29.50
2006-2008 LINGERIE SEDUCTION Cassandra Lynn #03
$6.50
2014 FLO JALIN BENCHWARMER 2/3 GREEN FOIL HOCKEY PREMIUM BASE CARD
$3.95
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER STEPHANIE BRANTON EXTRA CREDIT GEMS CARD /3
$2.55
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER TIFFANY SELBY GOLD FOIL BASE CARD /25
$0.99
2018 Benchwarmer Hot For Teacher Cassandra Lynn Premium Base Green Foil 2/3
$1.25
2018 BENCHWARMER CARD HOT TEACHER YEARBOOK AUTOGRAPH ALLIE MASON 2/5 BLUE FOIL
$0.99
Benchwarmer 2013 Sandra Taylor 4th of July Red Ink Variant Auto Autograph
$0.99
Benchwarmer 2013 Andrea Lowell 4th of July Green Ink Variant Auto Autograph
$0.99
Benchwarmer 2016 Dani Mathers Dreamdate Gold Foil Auto Autograph
$0.99
Benchwarmer 2012 Kara Monaco 4th of July Auto Autograph
$0.99
Benchwarmer 2012 Paige Peterson Daizy Dukez Gold Auto Autograph
$0.99
Benchwarmer 2016 Qiana Chase Dreamdate Gold Foil Auto Autograph
$0.99
2018 BENCHWARMER HOT FOR TEACHER BRYIANA NOELLE GOLD FOIL BASE CARD /25
$0.99
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11100
Card Gallery of the Day: 2011 Benchwarmer Bubble Gum Trading Cards Part 1 (Photos)
Considering the set is relatively affordable for $10-$15 a pop on eBay, it's not a bad collectible to pick up. (Click here for the 2011 Benchwarmer Bubble Gum Base Cards Part 1) Here is the press release and info about the set... Bench Warmer goes "Old ...